Thursday, February 3, 2022

Earlier this week we had a post introducing SEC comment letters: what they are, how to find them in Calcbench, and an example of what such letters can say about a company’s financial reporting.

Today let’s look at the bigger picture: How many SEC comment letters get written?

To answer that question, we examined the SEC comment letters publicly released for 2020 and 2021. In short, there was a lot of commenting. 2021 saw a total of 10,278 letters exchanged between the SEC and companies. Of that total, 4,185 letters were sent by the SEC, and the remaining 6,093 were sent by the companies.

Those 4,185 comment letters sent by the SEC went to 2,226 companies — meaning that each of those companies received an average of 1.88 SEC comment letters last year. And since 2,226 companies are only about one-third of all publicly traded companies, it also means that a solid majority of companies received no comments from the SEC in 2021.

Also, of the 2,226 companies that received letters, only 79 were in the S&P 500 so most recipients of comment letters are smaller firms.

All of that is to be expected, by the way. The Sarbanes-Oxley Act requires the SEC to review the financial filings of every publicly traded company at least once every three years, so it’s not unusual for a majority of firms not to receive a comment letter in any given year; it’s not their turn. Moreover, most comment letters will say something along the lines of, “We looked at your filings and have no further questions,” a conversation that can be had in one or two letters at most.

Comment Letters Over Time

2021 shows a slight decrease compared to 2020. In 2020 the SEC sent 5,273 letters to 2,591 companies, so again, a similar average of 2 letters per company. The companies replied in 6,219 letters.

The chart below shows the distribution of letters across the year for 2020 and 2021. A dip happened in 2021 in April and May, followed by another dip later in the year. We do not see the same declines for 2020. It is interesting that the number of letters sent in early 2021 exceeded the number for the same period in 2020.

Also remember that SEC comment letters don’t always immediately become public once they’re sent. In most cases, the SEC delays the release of the comment letters.

According to the SEC, the comment letters become public no sooner than 20 business days after the SEC has completed its review of the company’s periodic or current report or declared a registration statement effective. This may explain the decline towards the end of 2021.

FREE Calcbench Premium
Two Week Trial

Research financial & accounting data like never before. Get features designed for better insights. Try our enhanced Excel Add-in. Sign up now to try the Premium Suite.